Playing in Googlebots Sandbox with Slurp, Teoma, & MSNbot - Spiders Display Differing Personalities
There has been endless webmaster speculation and worry about the so-called "Google Sandbox" - the indexing time delay for new domain names - rumored to last for at least 45 days from the date of first "discovery" by Googlebot. This recognized listing delay came to be called the "Google Sandbox effect."
Ruminations on the algorithmic elements of this sandbox time delay have ranged widely since the indexing delay was first noticed in spring of 2004. Some believe it to be an issue of one single element of good search engine optimization such as linking campaigns. Link building has been the focus of most discussion, but others have focused on the possibility of size of a new site or internal linking structure or just specific time delays as most relevant algorithmic elements.
Rather than contribute to this speculation and further muddy the Sandbox, we'll be looking at a case study of a site on a new domain name, established May 11, 2005 and the specific site structure, submissions activity, external and internal linking. We'll see how this plays out in search engine spider activity vs. indexing dates at the top four search engines.
Ready? We'll give dates and crawler action in daily lists and see how this all plays out on this single new site over time.
* May 11, 2005 Basic text on large site posted on newly purchased domain name and going live by days end. Search friendly structure implemented with text linking making full discovery of all content possible by robots. Home page updated with 10 new text content pages added daily. Submitted site at Google's "Add URL" submission page.
* May 12 - 14 - No visits by Slurp, MSNbot, Teoma or Google. (Slurp is Yahoo's spider and Teoma is from Ask Jeeves) Posted link on WebSite101 to new domain at Publish101.com
* May 15 - Googlebot arrives and eagerly crawls 245 pages on new domain after looking for, but not finding the robots.txt file. Oooops! Gotta add that robots.txt file!
* May 16 - Googlebot returns for 5 more pages and stops. Slurp greedily gobbles 1480 pages and 1892 bad links! Those bad links were caused by our email masking meant to keep out bad bots. How ironic slurp likes these.
* May 17 - Slurp finds 1409 more masking links & only 209 new content pages. MSNbot visits for the first time and asks for robots.txt 75 times during the day, but leaves when it finds that file missing! Finally get around to add robots.txt by days end & stop slurp crawling email masking links and let MSNbot know it's safe to come in!
* May 23 - Teoma spider shows up for the first time and crawls 93 pages. Site gets slammed by BecomeBot, a spider that hits a page every 5 to 7 seconds and strains our resources with 2409 rapid fire requests for pages. Added BecomeBot to robots.txt exclusion list to keep 'em out.
* May 24 - MSNbot has stopped showing up for a week since finding the robots.txt file missing. Slurp is showing up every few hours looking at robots.txt and leaving again without crawling anything now that it is excluded from the email masking links. BecomeBot appears to be honoring the robots.txt exclusion but asks for that file 109 times during the day. Teoma crawls 139 more pages.
* May 25 - We realize that we need to re-allocate server resources and database design and this requires changes to URL's, which means all previously crawled pages are now bad links! Implement subdomains and wonder what now? Slurp shows up and finds thousands of new email masking links as the robots.txt was not moved to new directory structures. Spiders are getting errors pages upon new visits. Scampering to put out fires after wide-ranging changes to site, we miss this for a week. Spider action is spotty for 10 days until we fix robots.txt
* June 4 - Teoma returns and crawls 590 pages! No others.
* June 5 - Teoma returns and crawls 1902 pages! No others.
* June 6 - Teoma returns and crawls 290 pages. No others.
* June 7 - Teoma returns and crawls 471 pages. No others.
* June 8-14 Odd spider behavior, looking at robots.txt only.
* June 15 - Slurp gets thirsty, gulps 1396 pages! No others.
* June 16 - Slurp still thirsty, gulps 1379 pages! No others.
So we'll take a break here at the 5 weeks point and take note of the very different behavior of the top crawlers. Googlebot visits once and looks at a substantial number of pages but doesn't return for over a month. Slurp finds bad links and seems addicted to them as it stops crawling good pages until it is told to lay off the bad liquor, er that is links by getting robots.txt to slap slurp to its senses. MSNbot visits looking for that robots.txt and won't crawl any pages until told what NOT to do by the robots.txt file. Teoma just crawls like crazy, takes breaks, then comes back for more.
This behavior may imitate the differing personalities of the software engineers who designed them. Teoma is tenacious and hard working. MSNbot is timid and needs instruction and some reassurance it is doing the right thing, picks up pages slowly and carefully. Slurp has addictive personality and performs erratically on a random schedule. Googlebot takes a good long look and leaves. Who knows whether it will be back and when.
Now let's look at indexing by each engine. As of this writing on July 7, each engine also shows differing indexing behavior as well. Google shows no pages indexed although it crawled 250 pages nearly two months ago. Yahoo has three pages indexed in a clear aging routine that doesn't list any of the nearly 8,000 pages it has crawled to date (not all itemized above.) MSN has 187 pages indexed while crawling fewer pages than any of the others. Ask Jeeves has crawled more pages to date than any search engine, yet has not indexed a single page.
Each of the engines will show the number of pages indexed if you use the query operator "site:publish101.com" without the quotes. MSN 187 pages, Ask none, Yahoo 3 pages, Google none.
The daily activity not listed in the three weeks since June 16 above has not varied dramatically, with Teoma crawling a bit more than other engines, Slurp erratically up and down and MSN slowly gathering 30 to 50 pages daily. Google is absent.
Linking campaign has been minimal with posts to discussion lists, a couple of articles and some blog activity. Looking back over this time it is apparent that a listing delay is actually quite sensible from the view of the search engines. Our site restructuring and bobbled robots.txt implementation seems to have abruptly stalled crawling but the indexing behavior of each engine displays distinctly differing policy by each major player.
The sandbox is apparently not just Google's playground, but it is certainly tiresome after nearly two months. I think I'd like to leave for home, have some lunch and take a nap now.
Back to class before we leave for the day kiddies. What did we learn today? Watch early crawler activity and be certain to implement robots.txt early and adjust often for bad bots. Oh yes, and the sandbox belongs to all search engines.
SEO Keyword Research: 13 of the Biggest Mistakes You MUST Avoid Search Engine Journal
The Future of SEO: What SEO & Marketing Pros Need to Understand Search Engine Journal
SEM vs. SEO vs. PPC Defined: What’s the Difference? Search Engine Journal
How to Write SEO-Friendly Content in 2020 - VENTS Magazine
Three Off-Site Tactics That Seriously Boost SEO Traffic MarketingProfs.com
Here’s how to leverage long-tail keywords for your SEO Search Engine Land
Ongoing Education: Your Secret to SEO Success Search Engine Journal
Trend-Watcher: 6 New Ways to Do SEO in 2020 Business 2 Community
A 50-Point Audit for Getting Started with Local SEO Search Engine Journal
Real-Time Insight & Real-Time Action in SEO: How Automation Bridges the Gap Search Engine Journal
7 Ways to Improve Your Website's SEO Business.com
Google’s Baby Algorithms: How to Think About Them for SEO Search Engine Journal
What is SEO? businessjournaldaily.com
Google Launches New, Animated Video Series About SEO for Beginners Search Engine Journal
Basic SEO Tips Any Content Writer Should Know Business 2 Community
Let's Untangle the Knotty Mystery of SEO Radio World
SEO best practices support ADA compliance for digital accessibility Search Engine Land
5 Free Keyword Research Tools for SEO & PPC JumpFly PPC Advertising News
5 SEO Tips to Optimize Your Next Blog Post Business 2 Community
Google’s John Mueller Speaks on SEO for Dark Mode Websites Search Engine Journal
How to find your ideal SEO agency Search Engine Land
GoodFirms Unlocks the Most Trustworthy Digital Marketing and SEO Companies for November 2019 - PRNewswire
GoodFirms Unlocks the Most Trustworthy Digital Marketing and SEO Companies for November 2019 PRNewswire
Learn How to Make Search Engine Optimization (SEO) Work for You USGlass Metal & Glazing
Link Building for 2020: What Works and What to Avoid MarTech Advisor
TF-IDF: Can It Really Help Your SEO? Search Engine Journal
10 Best SEO Podcasts to Master the Art of SEO 99Signals - Tech News, Tech Hacks, & More
Why the University of Arizona changed its abbreviation for SEO Search Engine Land
Redefining SEO in the Age of Digital Transformation Destination CRM
5 Metrics Crucial to SEO Success PR News - For Smart Communicators
Tesla Solar: Is Google SEO the Only Issue? Market Realist
Video: Eric Enge on Google advice vs. real-world SEO experience Search Engine Land
5 SEO suggestions to market your food truck | Commentary Food Truck Operator
For SEO, How Fast Is Fast Enough? Practical Ecommerce
Scorecard: The New SEO Tool To Help Your Business Get Noticed Women Love Tech
Benchmarking Beyond SEO: What Competitors' Website Traffic Can Reveal Search Engine Journal
University of Arizona switches from UA to UArizona for SEO The Associated Press
Screaming Frog releases SEO Spider version 12.0 Search Engine Land
SEO: Google's BERT Update Helps Ecommerce Product Pages Practical Ecommerce
How to Boost SEO for Coworking Spaces Commercial Property Executive
Why Discoverability Needs to Be an SEO Focus with Garrett Mehrguth [PODCAST] - Search Engine Journal
Why Discoverability Needs to Be an SEO Focus with Garrett Mehrguth [PODCAST] Search Engine Journal
The psychology of SEO on Brains Byte Back The Sociable
Travel SEO: 8 Ways to Build Links & Get Press as a Travel Brand Search Engine Journal
Barry Schwartz on Covering SEO News, Productivity & How to Grow a Business [PODCAST] - Search Engine Journal
Barry Schwartz on Covering SEO News, Productivity & How to Grow a Business [PODCAST] Search Engine Journal
An Introduction to Python for Technical SEO Search Engine Journal
Pro Rank Tracker Launches Lite Tool Rankitor, with Plans Starting at $5 Search Engine Journal
How to find cheap & affordable SEO services Business MattersBusiness Matters
How to Create Content For Terrific Website SEO Business 2 Community
SEO 2020: Top 15 Google Page Ranking Factors hypebot.com
Voice Search SEO: How To (Step-by-Step Guide) Business 2 Community
SEO Link-building for Ecommerce Practical Ecommerce
Recovery From November 2019 Google Update Search Engine Journal
Baidu SEO: Content Delivery, Speed & Accessibility Search Engine Journal
Could Blogging Boost Your Ecommerce SEO? Practical Ecommerce
5 DIY SEO Tips That Your Small Business Needs Business.com
How Google's BERT SEO Update Will Impact Content and Search PR News - For Smart Communicators
Google BERT Update – What it Means Search Engine Journal
Minok Seo, of Bristow won $152,973 PotomacLocal.com
11 Tools to Use for Your YouTube SEO Business 2 Community
Struggling with ROI on SEO? Here are five steps to better returns Marketing magazine Australia
SEO from Expired Domains - DNW Podcast #258 Domain Name Wire
Is SEO really beneficial for smaller businesses? Business MattersBusiness Matters
SEO Specialist job with Creative Circle | 406576 mediabistro.com
Video: Eric Enge on building and selling his SEO agency Search Engine Land
Long Island SEO Company, fishbat, Offers 3 Ways Fast Food Chains Can Profit From Social Media Influencer Promotions - PRNewswire
Long Island SEO Company, fishbat, Offers 3 Ways Fast Food Chains Can Profit From Social Media Influencer Promotions PRNewswire
The Truth About Multiple H1 Tags and SEO Business 2 Community
SEO Analyst job with Creative Circle | 406533 mediabistro.com
5 Reasons Your Business Needs to Invest in SEO in 2020 Promotion World
Writing articles for good SEO Market Business News
Creative & SEO Copywriter, Penguin General - London The Bookseller
Basics of Search Engine Optimization | Calendar Rutland Herald
Expedia Suffers Major Decline, Blames the Changing SEO Landscape Business Deccan
What takes an SEO firm into top ranks? Deadline News
Tremendous Growth Report on Search Engine Optimization (SEO) Software Market 2019-2025 with Major Key Player like Moz Pro, WordStream, SpyFu & More - Market Report Gazette
Tremendous Growth Report on Search Engine Optimization (SEO) Software Market 2019-2025 with Major Key Player like Moz Pro, WordStream, SpyFu & More Market Report Gazette
SEO Testing Service Market Research Report (2019-2025): New Opportunities, Key Trends and Growth Factors | SEO Tester Online, WebDepend, Click Information System - Daily Watch Reports
SEO Testing Service Market Research Report (2019-2025): New Opportunities, Key Trends and Growth Factors | SEO Tester Online, WebDepend, Click Information System Daily Watch Reports
Whats All This Hype About Links?
What's all the talk about links we hear about? Reciprocal links? Non-reciprocal links? Targeted links? Link Popularity? I need links. You should have links.
How To Choose Keywords Before they Skyrocket in Popularity
Long before the days of researching phrases with the helpful online resources of today, the art of keyword/phrase selection was often left just to guesswork. However, guesswork by today's highly competitive standards is just not good enough.
SEO Expert Guide - Sitewide Optimization (part 4/10)
In parts 1 and 2 you learnt how to develop your online business proposition and how to generate a list of key word ingredients for your site optimization activity. You were also introduced to our mythical Doug (who sells antique doors, door handles, knockers, door bells or pulls and fitting services) in Windsor in the UK.
Search Engine Copywriting: Focus on One Topic
Perhaps the simplest of all the lessons I have learned about writing for search engines is to keep my pages simple. That is to say, whether I am thinking about my readers or about Google, there is a huge advantage to keeping most of your pages confined to a single topic.
A Play In The Sandbox Is Necessary
There has been a good deal written about the Google 'sandbox' effect, as it's known. It has been taking up a lot of forum and article space over the last few months.
Are You Making These Deadly SEO Mistakes?
Black Hat SEO: Web Spamming and Linking to Bad NeighborhoodsSo you want to exchange links with other web sites in order to get higher search engine rankings?So you want to create hundreds of auto-generated, keyword rich pages for your site?Before you go and link to every website that is willing to exchange links, it would be a good idea to know where not to link to. Sometimes it can mean not linking to your own sites.
Winning the Search Engine Wars!
Creating and building effective Search Engine marketing campaigns is like trying to nail jello to the wall! The challenge can be daunting to many, requiring very specialized knowledge of process that must be blended with unique and disparate technology. Here is some insight gained from years of experience providing these services to clients.
Search Engine Success & The Google-Vision Secret
Want to know the secret to great search engine listings? Ignore Google.No, I'm not crazy.
Search Engine Visibility - The Mantra of Corporate Profitability
The corporate fundamentals are par excellence! The product is unsurpassable and the website is a web designer's dream in creativity and design - but there is a vacuum - of potential online customers! - The website lacks the basic ingredient of success - Search Engine Visibility! - which is what search engine optimization is all about.Increasing the search engine visibility is vital to any online business.
Search Bots, Crawlers, and Spiders
If you are a webmaster and you review your logs, often you will see a bunch of really strange hits. They aren't humans, you can't tell their operating system or their browser! Who are these pesky little creatures who rummage around the internet all the time?Not quite sure what I am talking about? Here is a few examples of various bots searching my website:207.
SEO and Directories
If you are a webmaster, then you've probably submitted your website to several directories, you may even run one yourself. There are thousands and thousands of directories out there on the net and they all have their advantages and disadvantages.
Emerging Methods for Effective Search Engine Ranking
Search Engine traffic has always been and continues to be one of the best ways to drive qualified traffic to a web site - it presents information about goods and services when the interest level is high and it can be acted on immediately. Up till now opt-in e-mail marketing has been an effective complement to search engine ranking campaigns; but the never-ending deluge of Spam is rapidly ruining the effectiveness of opt-in e-mail and helping to add luster to the value and cost-effectiveness of search engine traffic.
The Real Search Engine Optimization Guide
Nowadays, there is so much talk about SEO (search engine optimization) that it has become an industry of its own. Still, 90% of webmasters don`t know how to achieve high search engine positions.
Local Search Optimization - A Guide to Getting Started
While searching the web these days, it's hard not to notice all those little Local tabs sprouting up in the vicinity of the search field on virtually every major search engine. Within the past year, the race has been to integrate a plethora of advanced features into local search capabilities.
Optimize Your Site Pt1
Listed here you will find the five of the most important points to remember when optimising your site and individual pages for the search engines.If you optimise your pages by working through these points one by one you will see a significant rise in your search engine rankings.
Black Hat SEO and the Sneaky Redirect
Are shades of grey SEO really Black Hat SEO?Black hat SEO is a strategy which gets a web page or entire site banned from a search engine.A shade of grey is when you use a black hat strategy but your site has not been banned yet.
Gaining Additional PageRank
Google is the major search engine webmasters have to deal with in regards to gain traffic from a search engine. Yes, Yahoo and MSN are big, too - but they are only follow-ups compared to Google's popularity.
Search Engine Optimization Techniques
Search engine optimization is the process of increasing the amount of visitors to a website by achieving a high ranking in the search results of a search engine (i.e.
Google Rankings - Achieving a Top 10 Position in Google - Part 1
Achieving a top ranking position in Google is every webmasters dream. Unfortunately very few ever make it high enough for it to make a big difference on their traffic volume.
How and When Should I Submit My Website to Google?
As soon as you register your domain name, submit it to Google! Even if you haven't built your site, or written an copy, or even thought about your content, submit your domain name to Google. In fact, even if you haven't fully articulated your business plan and marketing plan, submit your domain name to Google.
|home | site map|