Why SEO (as we know it) is Doomed to Failure and How You Can Avoid the Trap
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) has become one of the biggest internet buzz-words recently. Everyone is talking about it. These days it seems there's an "expert" around every corner promising all kinds of wonderful things to online business owners. Beware! If you are interested in building a long term successful online business, there are few things you should know when it comes to search engine optimization.
Before we move too far along we need to understand a little about the economics of search engines. This will give us a better understanding of why they behave the way they do and why common Search Engine Optimization (SEO) practices will continue to provide diminishing returns, eventually into obscurity.
Contrary to a very common belief, internet users searching the web are not the search engine's customers. Advertiser's are. Just follow the trail of money and you'll see what I mean. Internet users are the "product" that the search engines "deliver" to advertisers. Specifically they are selling highly targeted traffic to their advertising clients. When a user types in search criteria, they are expressing their desire for information (or products) related to those search terms. By delivering ads that are directly relevant to the search results, search engines are in a unique position to capitalize on the concept of targeted traffic. For advertisers, search engine users are a gold mine of pre-qualified potential customers and they are quite happy to pay a premium to get their products in front of them.
So now that that's out of the way, how do search engines (SEs) compete with each other for those advertising dollars? The answer is two-fold and closely resembles the way any marketer goes about increasing sales. The first is obviously to get more traffic to the search engine. The second is to increase the conversion rate of that traffic. In other words the percentage of traffic that results in sales for the advertising clients. So if you own a search engine how do you accomplish these two things? The answer lies in delivering the best search results for any given search criteria. The more relevant the results that a search engine can deliver consistently, the more people will rely on it. This translates into more overall traffic and better targeting of ads to that traffic. Simple in concept... very complex in practice!
A little history lesson
In the beginning, search engines employed some rather primitive methods of determining a web page's relevance to a search query. These methods proved to be quite simple to reverse engineer and as a result "Search Engine Optimizers" (SEOers) where able to use techniques to manipulate the search results in their favor. This abuse, often referred to as SE spam undermined the search engine's main commodity, the quality and relevancy of it's contextual search results. To combat the problem, the SEs developed increasingly complex mathematical algorithms to evaluate pages for possible inclusion in search engine result pages (SERPs). In addition to the traditional "on-page" information that was so easy to manipulate, many SEs began looking at a multitude of "off-page" criteria and giving them an increasing amount of weight in their overall equations.
On-page vs. off-page criteria
There are many different items that a SE looks at "on-page" when it evaluates it. The page's title, how many occurrences of a searched word or phrase (keywords and key phrases) are on the page and their proximity to one other, what the headings on the page describe, etc. all come into play. The chief disadvantage of using only this information (aside from the ease of which it can be manipulated by clever SEOers), is that it tells nothing about the quality of the information on the page. Until the day comes (and it is coming) when search technology and computing power are sufficient to take advantage of "artificial intelligence" to make sound judgements about the quality of a page by evaluating the page alone, SEs will continue to rely heavily on "off-page" criteria. The reason for this is simple. Nothing compares to human intelligence when judging a page's importance. Computers running even the most complex algorithms simply can't do it.
So instead, the bright people who develop search engine technology have realized that by tracking how humans behave and interact with a web page, they can get a fairly good idea of how humans rate that page and the quality of it's information. This is the "off-page" criteria that we are talking about. There are hundreds if not thousands of different things that are tracked and evaluated "off-page". We know, or at least can make some pretty educated guesses as to what some of these things are. For instance, it is obvious from the collective experiences of many web professionals that SEs keep track of how many links come into a site from pages on other sites with high quality, relevant information. A link from such a source tells the SE that the information on the site that is being linked to is likely to be credible and of high quality as well. A human with related quality information on their site did link to it after all. It's also widely accepted that search engines monitor their own search engine result pages (SERPs) to determine such things as which results are getting the most clicks (it's not always the top ones) and how long it is before the searcher returns to the SERPs to continue searching. Obviously if the fifth site on the list is getting more clicks, it's probable that it appears to more closely match what the searcher is looking for than the ones above it. Furthermore, if the user stays on that site for an hour rather than five seconds it's likely that they found what they were looking for and the SE will take these things into account.
There are perhaps a handful of individuals in the world who know the whole picture of how all of this happens and if they want to keep their high paying jobs at the major SEs, they're not about to tell you or me. But it has led to a lot of speculation among SEOers. In fact the SEO industry has evolved into a world-wide phenomena with "professional SEO consultants" charging companies tens of thousand of dollars to "get their web site into the top 10". Some SEOers are continuously dreaming up ways of tricking the engines without getting "sandboxed" (having the engine penalize a web site by dropping it's rank). The SEs in turn regularly update and change the algorithms that they use to rank pages so that what worked yesterday in SEO may not apply today. The SEOers scramble to catch up and the continuous cycle of "algorithm chasing" continues.
SE's employ some of the most brilliant mathematicians and computer scientists on the planet and the unfortunate truth is that SEOers will always be at least one step behind them. Next time someone tells you that they can guarantee you a spot in the "top ten" with the major search engines ask yourself this one question. "Are they trying to sell me something?" Then walk away.
Now don't get me wrong here. I'm not against SEO or anyone who does it. I fact, I firmly believe that a certain amount of optimization is vital to any online marketing effort, particularly at the outset of a campaign. It serves to give a site that little push in the right direction towards building traffic. But I caution anyone not to take it too far. It's very easy to misplace too much emphasis on it.
So what do we do instead?
This one's easy. Rather that playing the SEO numbers game with the SEs, we instead give them exactly what they're looking for in the first place. If you recall from earlier, SEs are trying to learn from and indeed relying heavily on human behavior patterns to rate search results. The are on a mission to provide results and information that are highly relevant and real to searchers (in other words, human beings). So, provide information that is highly relevant to humans and the rest will fall into place naturally and organically. It may take a little longer, but the results will be worth it. Believe me!
Let me illustrate with a couple of examples
John decides that he would like to build a web site and make some money online. He builds a rather elaborately designed site and proceeds to optimize it to death. John's been reading all about optimization strategies and he pulls out all the stops on this one. He has a page title that's twenty-five words long (most of which have nothing to do with each other). He's packed the text of his pages full of his favorite keywords to the point that they are nearly incomprehensible to a normal reader (but the search engines "love them"). He's cross linked every page so many times that people are actually getting lost on his little 5 page site because they're clicking on every second word which is underlined. But it doesn't stop there. He then goes out and submits to every search engine and directory known to man regardless of locale of relevancy to his topic. He joins a few link exchanges and starts trading links with anyone who will reciprocate no matter how poor their site is. Maybe he even pays for a few "high rank links". You get the idea. Before he knows it his site is showing up on the first page of the SERPs of all the major search engines and he's sitting back patting himself on the back for a job well done.
Mary on the other hand comes up with and idea for an online business web site based on her area of expertise and after researching and identifying a niche in the market. She goes about building a nice simple cleanly designed web site that is logical an easy to use. She puts a lot of time and effort drawing on her experience and skills to write high quality content that is helpful to her visitors (or rather will be when she has some). After writing fifteen or twenty pages of original article content, she decides that she too should do some "optimizing". At this point she's realizes that the "on-page" SOE is already more or less done. Her keywords and key phrases (which she carefully researched from day one) are appearing naturally though out her articles, her page titles are reflective of the content of the pages, her headings are also aptly descriptive, and her pages navigate with function and simplicity. So, she moves on to the "off-page" optimization. She submits her site to the major search engines and directories. She then researches local and industry related directories and submits to them as well. Finally she identifies several well ranked important sites with in-demand content that is complimentary to her own and will be of use to her visitors (or rather will be when she has some). She drops a friendly e-mail to the owners of these sites outlining the possible benefits of a reciprocal link arrangement. Most, sadly, don't reply but a couple of enlightened ones do. After reviewing her site they agree that it could be beneficial to their users as well and set up a link to her site. Mary spends the next several months occasionally checking her traffic stats, her rank in the search engines etc., but finds she is still way down on the SERPs if she's on them at all. Not one to be discouraged though, she continues to churn out several solid articles a week and add them to her site.
Now remember John? He's been sitting back riding the wave of initial success for the last few months. He's even made a few sales. But then he starts to notice a disturbing trend. His site is slowly falling in the SERPs and his traffic is dropping off. People are visiting but they aren't staying long and they're certainly not buying anything. He also begins to notice that the large number of links he had pointing to his site are disappearing at an alarming rate. Try as he might, he just can't seem to turn it around...
Mary's spent the last few months patiently waiting for traffic and continuing to add excellent content to her site. And then it happens. First, a trickle of visitors come. She can see from her server logs that they are being referred from those well-chosen link partners she made agreements with. The search engines have also discovered those links and noticed the high quality sources that they are coming from. They represent a pretty good endorsement and the SE's are starting to realize that Mary's site must have something useful to offer. Consequently Mary's rank starts to improve. Now people begin to find her in the SEs. Even though her site is still a page or two down in the SERPs people seem to like the description and they're visiting. They're also staying on her site for long periods of time reading all of her superb content, The search engines once again conclude (and quite rightly) from tracking this behavior that Mary's site is worth even more rank. Finally the day comes when Mary find's her site at the top of the SERPs for her chosen keywords and she has a large amount of targeted traffic coming in. She doesn't quit though. She continues to create new and interesting content and her business continues to grow and prosper. Why? Because she continues to provide exactly what the SEs want. The same high quality content that human searchers are looking for.
...And where did things fall apart for poor John? Well, most of his "link exchange" partners suffered the same fate he did. The SEs noticed the irrelevancy of the links and dropped their weight to zero. His visitors coming in through his first page SERP placement where hitting the back button on their browsers as soon as they realized that John's site was of absolutely no use to them (even if they could read it or figure out how to use it). Eventually people stopped clicking those links altogether. Additionally, one of the major SEs went through an algorithm change during that time period causing John's site to lose some additional rank. Things just kind of slid downhill. Did John not work hard enough on his business? Actually in the beginning John worked very hard and the short-term results proved it. The problem is that he concentrated way too much of his effort in the wrong areas. In the long run instead of building a viable online business, all he ended up doing was playing a complex game of "chase the algorithm" with the SEs for a short time (and big surprise, he lost). Oh well, it was fun while it lasted...
I realize that the above examples are a bit of a simplification. But the bottom line is that as search engines become increasingly sophisticated and try harder than ever to deliver results that are real and relevant to humans, you can make your life and theirs much more lucrative by just giving them what they want from the start. Leave the math to the mathematicians and the tricky SEO to the SEOers and go about creating compelling content that humans and search engines alike will love.
Colin Plant is the owner of AtHomeBusinessNetwork.com a resource and community web site for people who have an interest in developing and running successful online home based businesses. He is also the principal of Concept Dynamics Interactive, a full service web design and multimedia firm.
Video: Ben Cook on site migrations & the earlier days in SEO Search Engine Land
12 Ways to Build a Winning SEO Strategy on a Small Budget Search Engine Journal
Google Introduces Beta Explanations that Can Explain Smaller Issues with SEO Marketing Campaigns - Inc.
Google Introduces Beta Explanations that Can Explain Smaller Issues with SEO Marketing Campaigns Inc.
What Are Managed SEO Services? The Daily Campus
WordPress SEO Beyond the Basics: 8 Things You Must Do Next Search Engine Journal
The five trends defining SEO and content marketing careers Marketing Week
Coaching SEO To Win Forbes
SEO myths busted by an ex-Googler Search Engine Land
The 8 Benefits of SEO for Ecommerce Practical Ecommerce
John Mueller Surprises with Answer to a Negative SEO Question Search Engine Journal
The HOTH Now Provides More Than 20 SEO Tools On Their Website That Anyone Can Use At No-Cost - PR Web
Importance and Advantages of Using SEO to Your Business The African Exponent
How to Make SEO Happen in 2020 Practical Ecommerce
Should You Be Buying Links for SEO in 2020? Business 2 Community
8 Tried & Tested Tips for Improving SEO & Developer Relations Search Engine Journal
Gary Illyes Teaches SEO With SEO Periodic Table :) Search Engine Roundtable
Why SEO is Important for Your Business Business 2 Community
Google’s John Mueller: Never Blindly Follow Big Sites’ SEO Search Engine Journal
Video: Jeff Selig on the early days of SEO, Google algorithms & international SEO - Search Engine Land
Video: Jeff Selig on the early days of SEO, Google algorithms & international SEO Search Engine Land
SEO Is Everyone’s Responsibility: 5 Tips to Get Non-SEOs Bought Into SEO Search Engine Journal
Why Amazon success requires a holistic approach to SEO and advertising DigitalCommerce360
How to Monitor SEO Topic Clusters, Silos Practical Ecommerce
Reciprocal Links: Do They Help or Hurt Your SEO? Search Engine Journal
Why SEO is an Essential Puzzle of Digital Marketing Business 2 Community
SEM vs. SEO vs. PPC Defined: What’s the Difference? Search Engine Journal
How Does SEO Work? JumpFly PPC Advertising News
How to Create a Superior SEO Strategy Business.com
Here’s Why Inclusive Web Design with SEO Wins 2020 Search Engine Journal
iWriter's Recent Article Answers the Common SEO Question: The Best Article Length to Maximize the SEO Benefits - PR Web
iWriter's Recent Article Answers the Common SEO Question: The Best Article Length to Maximize the SEO Benefits PR Web
How to Write SEO Proposals That Prove Your Value & Eliminate Client Concerns - Search Engine Journal
How to Write SEO Proposals That Prove Your Value & Eliminate Client Concerns Search Engine Journal
Elevating Women in SEO: The Industry Still Has a Long Way to Go Search Engine Journal
Managing Successful SEO Migrations Search Engine Journal
Basic SEO Tips Any Content Writer Should Know Business 2 Community
Podcasts & SEO: How to Make Your Podcast SEO-Friendly Search Engine Journal
What is Data Driven SEO? GISuser.com
Patent: Google Going Old School with Local SEO, But In A New Way Search Engine Journal
SEO Trends SEO in 2020 - 8 SEO Experts share their views on the future of SEO in 2020 - GlobeNewswire
Watch: Park Hang-seo tries to enter stadium again post SEA Games 2019 red card, fights with referee - FOX Sports Malaysia
Watch: Park Hang-seo tries to enter stadium again post SEA Games 2019 red card, fights with referee FOX Sports Malaysia
Seo-Ho Lee, Rohini Narayanan and Thomas Coulouras: Youth press Neal to support Green New Deal - GazetteNET
Seo-Ho Lee, Rohini Narayanan and Thomas Coulouras: Youth press Neal to support Green New Deal GazetteNET
After red card, Vietnam coach Park Hang-seo argues with Indonesia fans in stands at SEA Games 2019 - FOX Sports Malaysia
After red card, Vietnam coach Park Hang-seo argues with Indonesia fans in stands at SEA Games 2019 FOX Sports Malaysia
30+ SEO Stats from 2019 to Guide Your Strategy in 2020 and Beyond [Infographic] - Social Media Today
10 SEO factors that influence your Google ranking Eastbourne Herald
Sr. Manager, SEO job with NBCUniversal, Inc. | 407143 mediabistro.com
The Most Effective Link-Building Strategies According to SEO Experts MarketingProfs.com
SEO Company in Sydney Prepares for Rebranding in Early 2020 as Google Launches BERT - StreetInsider.com
SEO Company in Sydney Prepares for Rebranding in Early 2020 as Google Launches BERT StreetInsider.com
One Hundred Best SEO Companies Announced by topseos.com MarTech Series
The HOTH now offers free phone consultations with SEO experts to chat about effective strategies for increasing Google rankings. - Benzinga
The HOTH now offers free phone consultations with SEO experts to chat about effective strategies for increasing Google rankings. Benzinga
Misquoted and misunderstood: Why many in the search community don’t believe the WSJ about Google search - Search Engine Land
Misquoted and misunderstood: Why many in the search community don’t believe the WSJ about Google search Search Engine Land
WATCH: Vietnam coach Park Hang-seo shown red card for complaining to referee during SEA Games 2019 Men’s... - FOX Sports Malaysia
WATCH: Vietnam coach Park Hang-seo shown red card for complaining to referee during SEA Games 2019 Men’s... FOX Sports Malaysia
The Points Guy is Hiring The Points Guy
Dussty Scott of Get Found Fast – The Denver SEO Experts – to Speak at the Castle Rock Chamber of Commerce - StreetInsider.com
Dussty Scott of Get Found Fast – The Denver SEO Experts – to Speak at the Castle Rock Chamber of Commerce StreetInsider.com
The Best Free SEO Tools to Increase Your Rankings Entrepreneur
7 SEO best practices you should be doing regardless of what Google says Search Engine Land
What Does It Mean to ‘Do SEO’? Search Engine Journal
Hometown of popular football coach Park Hang-seo pushes to create Vietnam-style village - Viet Nam News
Hometown of popular football coach Park Hang-seo pushes to create Vietnam-style village Viet Nam News
Focus More Or Local SEO To Increase Local Engagement Promotion World
Seo Ye Ji being considered for female lead opposite Kim Soo Hyun in 'I'm a Psycho But It's Okay' - allkpop
Seo Ye Ji being considered for female lead opposite Kim Soo Hyun in 'I'm a Psycho But It's Okay' allkpop
My experience with SEO Practical Ecommerce
6 SEO Tips to Benefit Any Business Entrepreneur
7 Basic SEO Best Practices You Can Learn from Huge Travel Brands Search Engine Journal
What's the Value of SEO? Practical Ecommerce
Poll: After The SEO Audit; Next Steps Search Engine Roundtable
SEO Keyword Research: 13 of the Biggest Mistakes You MUST Avoid Search Engine Journal
Can SEO Be Made Predictable? Search Engine Journal
Developing Evolutions in Global SEO Software Market by New Business Developments, Development, and Dynamics Forces | Top Companies: HubSpot, Pro Rank Tracker, SEMrush, SEOmoz, and NinjaCat - Market Report Gazette
Developing Evolutions in Global SEO Software Market by New Business Developments, Development, and Dynamics Forces | Top Companies: HubSpot, Pro Rank Tracker, SEMrush, SEOmoz, and NinjaCat Market Report Gazette
6 Brilliant Reasons Why You Should Use SEO Tools Search Engine Journal
Ongoing Education: Your Secret to SEO Success Search Engine Journal
7 Best SEO Tools to Help You Rank Higher in Google Entrepreneur
Niche Marketing - Why Keyword Research Come First
A good portion of my business involves spending hours and hours using incredibly powerful but difficult to master software to uncover thousands of the exact, targeted keyword phrases people in any given niche market are typing into the search engines.When people new to the internet discover what I do and see the huge lists of keyword phrases and search data I uncover and compile, they often ask me what the heck it is used for.
Reciprocal Link Exchange Management Software
When shopping online for Link Management Software that can help create and automate your links directory, some important features that you should look for are as follows:The software should, Create the links page based on your own template. Allow addition or removal of links at the click of a button and have the links page rebuilt.
Banned By Google And Back Again
The date: 29th July 2005. The time: early morning.
Local Customers Know Where to Find Local Businesses... the Internet
Through search engines and directories, the Internet provides a quick and easy place to choose a local merchant or business.Just because the Internet is worldwide doesn't mean local businesses can't benefit from having a website and a presence in the search engines.
See No Google, Hear No Google, Speak No Google
That's right - I dreamt of a World Wide Web without the Googlopoly. And let me tell you - it was a scary place.
SEO, not again!, you may groan. The webmaster world is inundated by articles and "how to's" with regard to SEO (Search Engine Optimization).
Google's Siren Call - Is It Crashing Your Search Engine Marketing?
It's difficult to dispute the rational behind the rant since Google continues to outpace its rivals in popularity with an 89% "strongly positive experience" rating from an opinion poll of U.S.
Meta Tags - What Are They and Which Search Engines Use Them?
Defining Meta Tags is much easier than explaining how they are used, and by which engines. The reason is very few engines clearly lay out what they do and do not look at, and how much emphasis they put on any one factor.
3.5 Tips To Help You Avoid Becoming The Next Search Engine Outlaw
Want to avoid being blacklisted by the search engines and banished to the sin bin never to receive a single search engine visitor ever again? Thought so. Here's some tips to help you.
7 Search Engine Optimization Mistakes and Solutions
To many websites, webmasters discover that major sources of website traffic come from search engines. Therefore, they are all keen on gaining top search engine placements through search engine optimization.
The Real Search Engine Optimization Guide
Nowadays, there is so much talk about SEO (search engine optimization) that it has become an industry of its own. Still, 90% of webmasters don`t know how to achieve high search engine positions.
Link Building Services
In today scenario when we talk about Search Engine Optimization, we also talk about one of the most important aspect of SEO, which is Link Building. But there are different types, aspects and limitations of Link Building, which would be discussed now under1.
Linking Strategies to Skyrocket to the Top of Google
If you don't know already, one of the key success factors to getting loads of free Google traffic to your website is increasing page rank. So just how do you increase your page rank? Well, it's all in the linking.
Cracking the Google Code: Under the GoogleScope
Google's sweeping changes confirm the search giant has launched a full out assault against artificial link inflation & declared war against search engine spam in a continuing effort to provide the best search service in the world? and if you thought you cracked the Google Code and had Google all figured out ? guess again.Google has raised the bar against search engine spam and artificial link inflation to unrivaled heights with the filing of a United States Patent Application 20050071741 on March 31, 2005.
Many internet marketers blow mountains of start-up cash on their websites just trying to break into search engine rankings. I was one of these internet marketers.
Maximising Google's PageRank of Your Website to Maximise Traffic
Google uses PageRank to rank your pages. To maximize your rank, you must understand how to work with it.
Search Engines 101 - Search Engines Explained
What Are Search Engines?A search engine is a database system designed to index and categorize internet addresses, otherwise known as URLs (for example, http://www.submittoday.
Easy SEO in 6 Simple Steps
If you want to increase traffic to your website and better your search engine positioning, here is an easy 6 step process that will enable you to do so.1.
Submitting Your Site To The Open Web Directory: Some Dos And Don'ts
One of the most important steps in any site's publicity campaign is the submission to the Open Web Directory (http://www.dmoz.
Learn about the Google Search Engine Tools
Think you know everything about searching with Google? Think again. Believe it or not, there are many tools and features available on Google that can be useful for marketing research as well as wasting time.
|home | site map|